M-Shack's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Death Island]

huh?

Well the picture was interesting, the lil swirly things were too. But this is nothing. You're prolly going to be hated on for using the exact same audio as Boogleys latest submission. It's not synced up to the music, nothing happens, it seems more like a work in progress than an experiment. Maybe if you synced it up it would get a better score, but there's no real reason for ppl to watch this longer than the first loop. And if it ends, it's not a loop

Bjorvy responds:

Boogleys latest submission? I don't have a clue what you're talking about.

[Showreel Animation]

get a play button for the flash version so it...

doesnt loop
It wasnt bad, but nothing too spectacular in there. Some of the animation seemd slow, what frame rate do you use? I say if you work on some of the drawings more and just keep doing more animaiton you'll do well.

[Sketchy Friends Dance 2]

sigh

If only my friends were just as sketchy and danced :(

The purple girl seemed to barely move. I heard the beat she moved to, but she would only move to it when she got a solo with the frog. Is there something going on between them that you're not telling us?

Nice job, smooth as the white part of hard boiled, de-shelled, eggs

TheBoogley responds:

She's shy... you're the second person to mention that so I think I'll go back in there and fix it. :)

[Black vs White Tribute]

Pretty good

Everything was pretty fluid and the movements almost seemed a little more "realistic" than most stick fight movies. Good job on it.

[Pokemon: Fated Battle]

It was pretty good

I enjoyed it. I sat and watched the whole thing. You def put a lot of hard work into it. I woulda prolly given it a 9 if the drawings were better and some of the same attack animations werent used multiple times. Wasnt a fan of the people looking kind of DBZish

["Snowfall"]

haha

Really nice man. The animation was very smooth and the drawing style was great. It looked kind of like an old school cartoon and the MC looked a bit like a Charlie Brown character. Very nice. The only thing I think could have been a little better was the music. I get what you were trying to do, but I think another song might have fit better.

[The Proper Way]

haha

Oh man, that show was ridiculously great! lol

[Explosive joking]

Really nice

I like the classic style. i think you emulated it well. Maybe clean up the lines a bit, but animation was smooth and everything worked well. Good job.

[We practice melting?]

Nice for a start

It's a good exercise, but not really worth being submitted. Next step would be to keep the lines cleaner

TreasurePlanet responds:

thanks for the response.

[Harry The Harlequin Baby]

Very interesting

The content was twisted as fuck, but i believe in rating according to the content ALONG with quality of the work. The animation was great. Nice style, smooth, def took time and effort to complete. But man was it some creepy twisted shit. I guess that was kind of the idea tho, so good job?